Journal archive · Nasal tip · Open versus closed approach · 2012
Alar-columellar disharmony using the tongue-in-groove maneuver in primary endonasal rhinoplasty
Williams EF.
What this paper says
This technique article presents the tongue-in-groove suture, previously described through the open approach, as a long-term fix for a hanging columella done through incisions inside the nose, which the author states preserves more tip support; the abstract reports no patient counts.
Overview
When the columella hangs below the nostril rims, too much of it shows from the side. This alar-columellar disharmony is often overlooked in rhinoplasty and can spoil an otherwise good result. The tongue-in-groove maneuver tucks the inner legs of the tip cartilages back onto the septum to lift the columella. The author applies it through the closed approach in first-time rhinoplasty.
Sections of note
- Technique description; no series size, follow-up or outcome data in the abstract.
- Correction of alar-columellar disharmony is described as challenging and often neglected.
- The tongue-in-groove suture had been described in the literature via the open approach.
- The endonasal approach is stated to preserve greater tip support than the external approach.
- Presented as an effective long-term tool for the hanging columella together with other variant anatomy.
What it means for a patient
- A columella that shows too much from the side can be corrected by stitching the tip cartilages onto the septum, and this can be done without an external incision.
- The maneuver also sets tip position and rotation, so it changes more than the columella.
- No results are given in the abstract, so durability and complication rates cannot be judged from it.
Why this paper matters
Alar-columellar relationships are a frequent source of revision complaints, and the tongue-in-groove is one of the few maneuvers that addresses a hanging columella without removing cartilage. This paper extends it to the closed approach. Outcome data remain unreported.
Terms
- Alar-columellar disharmony: an imbalance between the nostril rim and the columella seen from the side, showing too much or too little columella.
- Columella: the strip of skin and cartilage between the nostrils.
- Hanging columella: a columella that sits too low below the nostril rims.
- Tongue-in-groove: setting the medial crura into a pocket on the caudal septum and suturing them there.
- Endonasal approach: rhinoplasty through incisions hidden inside the nostrils.
- Medial crura: the inner legs of the tip cartilages that run down the columella.
Summary written by rhinoplasty.cc from the abstract, 2026-09-08; not medical advice. The authors' own abstract follows. All 1,262 summaries.
From the abstract
“The correction of alar columellar disharmony can be very challenging and is often neglected during rhinoplasty. Failure to address alar columellar disharmony may adversely affect an otherwise satisfactory outcome. The tongue-in-groove suture technique has been described in the literature using an open approach as an…”
Excerpt; the full abstract is on PubMed.
Citation
Authors on this site
Start here
What the rhinoplasty literature says on this paper's topics, cited line by line to PubMed.
Nasal tip
Tip surgery is now a support problem rather than a sculpting problem: the septal extension graft holds projection and rotation where the columellar strut loses them (0.2% against 4.7% projection loss at one year), and the current series repair, reposition and reinforce the lower lateral cartilages instead of excising them.
Open versus closed approach
Whether the surgeon opens the nose through a small incision across the columella or works entirely through the nostrils has been argued in print since 1973, was put on facing pages of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery by Jack Gunter and Jack Sheen in 1997, and was finally pooled in 2025: across twenty studies and 1,067 patients there is no significant difference in what patients report, in breathing, in complications or in swelling.
Related papers
Same topic, 2012.
- APS Reverse nasal SMAS-perichondrium flap to avoid supratip deformity in rhinoplastyArslan E, Gencel E, Pekedis O2012PMID 21938592Summary
- APS Treatment of hyperdynamic nasal tip ptosis in open rhinoplasty: using the anatomic relationship between the depressor septi nasi muscle and the dermocartilaginous ligamentTellioglu AT, Inozu E, Ozakpinar R et al.2012PMID 22527586Summary
- Arch FPS 2012PMID 22006234Summary
- FPS Deprojection of the nasal tip in revision rhinoplastyKridel RW, Undavia SS2012PMID 22872560Summary
- FPS Nuances of the nasal tip: rhinoplasty of the thin-skinned noseFarrior EH, Ballert JA2012PMID 22562566Summary
- FPS 2012PMID 22562570Abstract
- FPS Tip nuances for the nose of African descentChike-Obi CJ, Boahene K, Bullocks JM et al.2012PMID 22562569Abstract
- PRS A new method for evaluating the outcome of rhinoplasty on the nasal tipYang Z, Tan X, Li H et al.2012PMID 22456400